Thursday, January 20, 2011

O impacto dos pais

Do parents matter?, por Chris Dillow:

Do parents matter? One way to find out is to compare how children who suffer the death of a parent fare in later life compared to those who don’t. This new paper does just this for Swedish kids, with results that might be surprising:

Parental death has surprisingly small average effects on cognitive outcomes, despite representing a traumatic shock. Given the size of our dataset, we can rule out zero effects, but our preferred estimates represent a loss of a couple of months of schooling.

The impact on subsequent earnings is also small - 6-7% for boys and 1-2% for girls.

Curiously, it doesn’t make much difference whether it is the mother or father who dies. Nor does a parent’s death when the child is young have a larger effect. If anything, the opposite - for boys, the death of a father before the age of 10 has no significant impact upon education, IQ or earnings.

Quite why this should be so is not so clear. It could be that the death of one parent causes the surviving one to try harder. In The Talent Code, Daniel Coyle suggests another possibility. The loss of a parent, he says, sends out a “primal cue” - that one is not safe, and had better work hard to make something of oneself. This, he says, unleashes the energy that is necessary for success: he lists a huge number of eminent people (Darwin, Newton, Lincoln, Gandhi, Dostoyevsky etc) who lost a parent when young.
Uma nota pessoal - dos melhores alunos (falo dos rapazes) da minha turma da secundário, o único que não era orfão era eu (e eu sou provavelmente o menos bem sucedido do grupo).

Uma teoria que me ocorre é que a educação paterna (e materna, já agora) talvez funcione mais pela negativa do que pela positiva - isto é, suspeito que uma "má educação" tem efeitos negativos significativos, mas que os efeitos de uma "boa educação" são largamente neutros (o que bate certo com isto).

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

O que é uma boa educação? Não é essa a questão?

Quando o pai ou a mãe morrem não será isso uma forma de educação, ou de pelo menos aprendizagem?